Edinboro University Athletics

Costello was the Edinboro soccer program's first and only United Soccer Coaches' Association All-American. She is a four-time All-PSAC selection with three first-team honors. As a defender, she ranks 12^th in career assists and 16^th in career points with 44. As a junior she was a unanimous all-region first-team selection.
 
In her senior season, she named the PSAC Defensive Player of the Year as well as earning unanimous recognition as a first-team all-region choice. She earned All-American honors from the United Soccer Coaches Association. Costello was a two-time team captain. In addition to her on-field accomplishments, she was an active member of the Student-Athlete Advisory Committee traveling to conferences and working on Make-a-Wish projects.
 
After graduation, Costello has taught in the Erie City and Millcreek Township School Districts for the past 10 years. She is currently teaching fifth grade in the Millcreek School District. She also coaches junior varsity girls' soccer at McDowell High School as well as middle school girls soccer.