| All-Time Records |
|
| Individual |
| Game |
| Most Points: 54 by Frank Smith vs. Fredonia State, 1966-67; 52 by Frank Smith vs. Kenyon, 1968-69 |
| Most Field Goals Made: 21 by Frank Smith vs. Waynesburg, 1966-67; by Frank Smith vs. Kenyon, 1968-69 |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals Made: 10 by Blake Johnson vs. Clarion, 2000-01; 10 by Jesse Ogden vs. Indiana(Pa.), 1996-97 |
| Most Free Throws Made: 18 by Bryan Theriot vs. Urbana, 2011-12 |
| Most Free Throws Attempted: 22 by Bryan Theriot vs. Urbana, 2011-12; by Jakim Donaldson vs. Clarion, 2002-03 |
| Most Consecutive Free Throws Made: 14 by Ken Gerber (14 of 14) vs. Gannon, 1961-62 |
| Most Rebounds: 39 by Don Dougan vs. Indiana(Pa.), 1964-65 |
| Most Assists: 20 by Larry Betar vs. California(Pa.), 1973-74; 19 by Dave Knowlton vs. Grove City, 1969-70 |
| Most Blocked Shots: 12 by Ryan McLemore vs. Slippery Rock, 2/13/08 |
|
| Season |
| Most Points: 800 by Tyrone Mason, 1995-96 |
| Highest Scoring Average: 30.1 by Frank Smith, 1966-67 |
| Most Field Goals Made: 307 by Tyrone Mason, 1995-96 |
| Most Field Goals Attempted: 594 by Tyrone Mason, 1995-96 |
| Highest Field Goal Percentage: .647 by Ricky Jordan, 1987-88 (141 of 218) |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals Made: 118 by Jesse Ogden, 1997-98 |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals Attempted: 286 by Jesse Ogden, 1997-98 |
| Highest 3-Point Field Goal Percentage: .523 by Dan Grabill, 2001-02 (45 of 86) |
| Most Free Throws Made: 139 by Billy Wade, 1989-90 |
| Most Free Throws Attempted: 210 by Daren Tielsch, 2005-06 |
| Highest Free Throw Percentage: .882 by Roy Stauffer, 1972-73 (90 of 102) |
| Most Consecutive Free Throws Made: 38 by Ken Gerber, 1961-62 |
| Most Rebounds: 406 by Jakim Donaldson, 2004-05 |
| Highest Rebounding Average: 18.5 by Darryl Meacham, 1966-67 |
| Most Assists: 273 by Adam Kaufman, 1997-98 |
| Most Steals: 128 by Fred Riley, 1970-71 |
| Most Blocked Shots: 170 by Ryan McLemore, 2007-08 |
|
| Career |
| Most Points: 1,954 by Tyrone Mason, 1993-96 |
| Highest Scoring Average: 23.6 by Tyrone Mason, 1993-96 |
| Most Field Goals Made: 720 by Tyrone Mason, 1993-96 |
| Most Field Goals Attempted: 1,508 by Don Lovett, 1976-80 |
| Highest Field Goal Percentage: .640 by Ricky Jordan, 1986-88 (249 of 389) |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals Made: 334 by Jesse Ogden, 1994-98 |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals Attempted: 815 by Jesse Ogden, 1994-98 |
| Highest 3-Point Field Goal Percentage: .428 by Jose Davis, 1986-88 (134 of 313) |
| Most Free Throws Made: 402 by Bryan Theriot, 2010-14 |
| Most Free Throws Attempted: 548 by Jakim Donaldson, 2001-05 |
| Highest Free Throw Percentage: .863 by Roy Stauffer, 1971-74 (239 of 277) |
| Most Rebounds: 1,100 by Jakim Donaldson, 2001-05 |
| Highest Rebounding Average: 12.8 by Darryl Meacham, 1963-67 |
| Most Assists: 936 by Adam Kaufman, 1997-01 |
| Most Steals: 246 by Fred Riley, 1969-72 |
| Most Blocked Shots: 354 by Ryan McLemore, 2004-08 |
Most Games Played: 120 by Devon Knight, 2004-08
|
| Team |
| Game |
| Most Points Scored: 133 vs. Lock Haven, 1967-68 |
| Most Points in a Half: 74 vs. Point Park, 1973-74 |
| Most Combined Points: 256 vs. West Virginia Wesleyan (West Virginia Wesleyan 129, Edinboro 127 2OT), 1990-91 |
| Most Field Goals Made: 54 vs. Lock Haven, 1967-68; vs. Alliance, 1973-74 |
| Most Field Goals Attempted: 114 vs. Mercyhurst, 1999-2000 |
| Most Free Throws Made: 41 vs. Urbana, 2011-12 |
| Most Free Throws Attempted: 56 vs. Urbana, 2011-12 |
| Highest Free Throw Percentage: 1.000 vs. Bloomsburg (12 of 12), 1998-99 |
| Most Rebounds: 93 vs. Clarion, 1968-69 |
| Longest Game: 5 overtimes vs. California(Pa.), 1988-89 |
|
| Season |
| Most Wins: 26 in 1997-98 |
| Most Losses: 17 in 1992-93; 1980-81 and 1955-56 |
| Fewest Wins: 0 in 1945-46 |
| Fewest Losses: 1 in 1931-32 |
| Highest Winning Percentage: .923 in 1931-32 (12-1) |
| Lowest Winning Percentage: .000 in 1945-46 (0-5) |
| Most Consecutive Wins: 13 in 1975-76 |
| Most Consecutive Losses: 12 in 1955-57 |
| Most Points Scored: 2,784 in 1997-98 |
| Highest Scoring Average: 89.4 in 1967-68 |
| Most Field Goals Made: 1,003 in 1997-98 |
| Most Field Goals Attempted: 2,231 in 1997-98 |
| Highest Field Goal Percentage: .513 in 1966-67 |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals Made: 247 in 1997-98 |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals Attempted: 670 in 1997-98 |
| Highest 3-Point Field Goal Percentage: .445 in 1987-88 |
| Most Free Throws Made: 531 in 1997-98 |
| Most Free Throws Attempted: 763 in 1985-86 |
| Highest Free Throw Percentage: .736 in 1990-91 |
| Most Rebounds: 1,385 in 1975-76 |
| Highest Rebounding Average: 55.7 in 1965-66 |
| Most Assists: 559 in 1990-91 |
| Most Turnovers: 506 in 1974-75 |
| Most Steals: 493 in 1970-71 |
| Most Blocked Shots: 244 in 2007-08 |
| Most Games: 34 in 1997-98 |
